VeggieBoards banner

I haven't always been a fan of how PETA approaches things

6175 Views 84 Replies 29 Participants Last post by  nogardsram
But I just read this and got a bit angry when I read this.

http://sev.prnewswire.com/publishing...0012008-1.html

PETA Killed 97 Percent of 'Companion Animals' in 2006, According to VDACS

Death toll up to 17,400; overdue report describes PETA's deadliest year ever

WASHINGTON, Jan. 10 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- An official report from People for The Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), submitted nine months after a Virginia government agency's deadline, shows that the animal rights group put to death more than 97 percent of the dogs, cats, and other pets it took in for adoption in 2006. During that year, the well-known animal rights group managed to find adoptive homes for just 12 pets. The nonprofit Center for Consumer Freedom (CCF) is calling on PETA to either end its hypocritical angel-of-death program, or stop its senseless condemnation of Americans who believe it's perfectly ethical to use animals for food, clothing, and critical medical research.

Not counting animals PETA held only temporarily in its spay-neuter program, the organization took in 3,061 "companion animals" in 2006, of which it killed 2,981. According to Virginia's Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (VDACS), the average euthanasia rate for humane societies in the state was just 34.7 percent in 2006. PETA killed 97.4 percent of the animals it took in. The organization filed its 2006 report this month, nine months after the VDACS deadline of March 31, 2007.

"Pet lovers should be outraged," said CCF Director of Research David Martosko. "There are thousands of worthwhile animal shelters that deserve Americans' support. PETA is not one of them."

In courtroom testimony last year, a PETA manager acknowledged that her organization maintains a large walk-in freezer for storing dead animals, and that PETA contracts with a Virginia cremation service to dispose of the bodies. In that trial, two PETA employees were convicted of dumping dead animals in a rural North Carolina trash dumpster.

Today in Southampton County, Virginia, another PETA employee will face felony charges in a dog-napping case. Andrea Florence Benoit Harris was arrested in late 2006 for allegedly abducting a hunting dog and attempting to transport it to PETA's Norfolk headquarters.

"PETA raised over $30 million last year," Martosko added, "and it's using that money to kill the only flesh-and-blood animals its employees actually see. The scale of PETA's hypocrisy is simply staggering."

To speak with a spokesman contact Tim Miller at 202-463-7112.

For more information about PETA's massive euthanasia program, visit http://www.PetaKillsAnimals.com.

Do you guys feel this is legit, or just some sort of stunt to try to hurt PETA's reputation? I'm new to the animal rights scene and got pretty confused reading this.
See less See more
1 - 20 of 85 Posts
I don't have as big of a problem with this known fact as I do most of their other "stunts". Sometimes euthanasia is the only humane option, especially when you're rescuing animals from horrible conditions. It is true though that they euthanised a lot of animals they could have rehomed, but even then it doesn't bother me as much since open access shelters understand the enormity of the situation--there aren't enough homes for all the animals that need them, some just simply are going to need to be killed.
Quote:
The nonprofit Center for Consumer Freedom (CCF) is calling on PETA to either end its hypocritical angel-of-death program,
How dare PETA try to clean up after the pet industry condoned by CCF and others.
But it makes you wonder if all of the animals "put down" actually needed it. I'd gather to say that many could have lived longer with proper medical and personal care. I will say that I agree with animals rights, but not with PETA. Just because PETA proclaims to do things the right way, and go against such abuse, I don't buy into it. Unless I am there first hand, and know the truth from seeing it as it happens, I don't believe it.
Look into who the CCF is so you too can immediately ignore anything they say.
I have to agree with KPick on this one. Working in animal rescue/shelters can pose many "Catch 22"-type situations. Sometimes you have to step away and look at the big picture in order to get a better view.
See less See more
Quote:
Originally Posted by SuperChicken View Post

Look into who the CCF is so you too can immediately ignore anything they say.
Whether or not you agree with PETA is one thing, but the CCF is another entirely. PETA nmay occasionally be earnestly wrong, but the CCF is nothing but a lobbyist group for bad things.

http://www.sourcewatch.org/wiki.phtm...nsumer_Freedom Here's one source, but look into what this group believes.
See less See more
I've seen this conversation on vegetarian boards just a few times. Ingrid Newkirk gave PETA's explanation, so there are two sides to this story. I don't agree with everything PETA has done, but the good far, far outweighs the bad they've done IMO.
Unfortunately, that CCF bull---- has been circulating all over the Internet. I've been posting in the comment sections of blogs to let people know who the CCF is. Please do the same. The more people who tell others about the hypocrisy and lies of the CCF, the better.
That's the first group I've ever seen claim obesity doesn't shorten life expectancy. Wow. What did PCRM do that angered them? I realize they're close to PETA, but they don't have quite their popularity so I'm surprised they'd target them.
PCRM promotes vegetarianism, and CCF is heavily influenced by the meat industry.

Hey, CCF, let's see some numbers on how many animals Tyson Meats (one of your funding surces) killed last year.
I just did a search on this, & the CCF release is being reported all over the place. Lots of angry comments being made about it on various forums. Lots of uninformed (or only partially informed) righteous belligerence against PETA. Many recommendations to view the Penn & Teller show on PETA. Many calling PETA hypocrites. Many stating a lack of surprise, since they already knew that "PETA doesn't believe anyone should have pets." Lots of outrage because the animals killed are those people generally view as having a special status (that of "pets"). Lots of fun new things to spell out using the PETA acronym! Like People Electrocuting and Torturing Animals! Ha ha ha ha ha!!! Ai-yi-yi.

It will be interesting to see what kind of response PETA makes. And how widely reported their response will be. They'll post some kind of defense, I imagine. Then probably just shrug it off, more or less, & get on with it.
See less See more
I worked at animal shelters for years...

You can be one of two kinds of animal shelter:

(actual numbers killed are higher in my city)

Kill:

You keep a certain number in an adoption lobby for a period of time, all 'extras' and those whose time is up go through the back door and get killed... Ultimately adopting out 5 per day, and killing about 100 per day.

No-Kill:

All the pets that make their way through your door have a home there until they are adopted. But, since you only adopt out 5 per day, but 100 per day are trying to get in...you have no choice but to turn people away...scrambling to write down license plate numbers of those who angrily announced they were going to shoot, drown, of throw their pets in the dumpster because you didn't take them...knowing the police aren't going to do anything.

At the no-kill shelter, my heart bled every day for dogs and cats that I knew were going to be dumped in the woods, dumpsters, or otherwise killed by someone who doesn't know how to kill an animal 'properly' and people who think that putting a cat in a pillowcase, taping it up, and cutting it in half with an axe is a suitable solution to their problem.

Sorry, I too don't agree with everything PeTA does...but dammit...

Sometimes you just have to pick the lesser of two evils...and sometimes you can't tell which is which!!!!!
See less See more
Well now I'm educated on who the CCF is and it makes sense why the put the release out. Should have done my homework ahead of time, but I appreciate the information. Pretty much just like every other lobbying body, able to spin anything to help promote their clients.
Quote:
Originally Posted by LovelyPerv View Post

Sorry, I too don't agree with everything PeTA does...but dammit...

Sometimes you just have to pick the lesser of two evils...and sometimes you can't tell which is which!!!!!
PETA has many of the same goals many people on this board have, so isn't it a bit of an exaggeration to consider them an evil?
Please, please respond to the comments you see. I've been posting every time the Peta release is posted on a blog or message board. But it may not help if I'm the only one. Thanks, guys!


And I'm surprised/annoyed that Peta hasn't responded to the CCF release. It's been out for a while, but is only now being plastered around by every CCF-ignorant person on the Internet.
See less See more
Quote:
Originally Posted by LovelyPerv View Post

Kill:

You keep a certain number in an adoption lobby for a period of time, all 'extras' and those whose time is up go through the back door and get killed... Ultimately adopting out 5 per day, and killing about 100 per day.
That pretty much describes my experience when I worked at a Humane Society shelter.
Quote:
Originally Posted by denise1021 View Post

Please, please respond to the comments you see. I've been posting every time the Peta release is posted on a blog or message board. But it may not help if I'm the only one. Thanks, guys!


And I'm surprised/annoyed that Peta hasn't responded to the CCF release. It's been out for a while, but is only now being plastered around by every CCF-ignorant person on the Internet.
CCF issued their press release on Jan 10 (Thursday); it was picked up by news orgs on Fri. PETA slows down its PR work over the weekends, so I wouldn't expect to see a response until Monday.
Quote:
Originally Posted by rainforests1 View Post

I've seen this conversation on vegetarian boards just a few times. Ingrid Newkirk gave PETA's explanation, so there are two sides to this story. I don't agree with everything PETA has done, but the good far, far outweighs the bad they've done IMO.
I must slightly agree. PETA may have it's faults... but I think it does far more good than bad.

It certainly educates people about the meat industry, that's for sure.
1 - 20 of 85 Posts
Top