VeggieBoards - Reply to Topic
Thread: Good Dog for an Apartment Reply to Thread
Title:
Message:
Trackback:
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:
 

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the VeggieBoards forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.
User Name:
If you do not want to register, fill this field only and the name will be used as user name for your post.
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.
Password:
Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.
Email Address:

Log-in


  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

  Topic Review (Newest First)
10-26-2008 01:09 PM
Calhoun07
Quote:
Originally Posted by SonicEarth View Post

I'll most likely be moving into an apartment after I graduate and am considering getting a dog. I don't want any toy dogs. I've been looking at whippets, and they seem fairly well-suited for apartments. The only problem is that I will be away at work for eight hours a day. What are some good breeds for apartments?



I haven't read through all the posts yet (the first reply sure got me riled up enough! ) so I don't know if you made your final decision yet or not, but let me throw my suggestion into the ring:



A golden retriever.



That's the dog I have. They are amazingly adaptable. They are a breed that would be equally happy in a house with a big back yard or in an apartment. And while I live in an one bedroom apartment with my dog, we get plenty of exercise outside walking around the apartment complex and going to the park, so it's not like he's confined to a small area all day every day.



Now, most apartments will have size restrictions on dogs. I found that those can be negotiated. My dog was the first large breed animal my apartment allowed, and now there are probably a half dozen or so pet owners here with large breed dogs.



The benefits for an apartment manager to permit large breed dogs (just my list, IMO)



1) large breed dogs tend to be more quite. Smaller dogs tend to bark more.



2) large breed dogs can hold their bladder longer. That's something to consider if you got a small dog and had to be at work for 8 hours a day.



3) large breed dogs tend to be more docile. Contrary to popular belief, they do NOT need large spaces to run around. My dog really doesn't run around that much at all when I take him out to play. Small dogs seem to have more energy to burn.



4) Small dogs tend to be more destructive. Any dog can cause damage, but that energy in a small dog has to come out some how. That's not a blanket condemnation of all small dogs, but that's just an observation I've had in my life where my family has had a good number of dogs over the years.





My point is large breed dogs can be good residents in an apartment, and I don't see any quantifiable reason apartment managers should put size limits on dogs. It should be considered more by breed. A beagle, for example, might be more docile than a dalmation, though the dalmation is considerably bigger than the beagle.



But I'd recommend a golden any day to a person who had to leave the animal alone. If the apartment manager says the dog is too big, there are more in depth articles on goldens and how suitable they are for apartment living that you can find online. Show them to the manager and make your case if they say no at first. My dog gets no complaints around here, he's a model resident.



Buy a Kong or get some good chews for the dog to play with when you leave for work (I advise STRONGLY against rawhides, however...they can easily get lodged in a dog's throat and cause them to choke. It happened to my dog and good thing I was home when it happened or he would have died.) But get a Kong, fill it with canned dog food, peanut butter, their favorite treats, and they will have something to preoccupy them when you are gone to work.
10-26-2008 12:57 PM
Calhoun07
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mrrple View Post

If your situation is one that you have to look at particular breeds to suit just your needs, then consider not getting a dog at all. You should always be looking at the dog's needs first and foremost.



That is just an ignorant comment. Why would you assume a dog "suffers" if they are on their own during a normal work day? By your standard, the only people who should have dogs are shut ins or families with a stay at home parent or somebody on unemployment or who only works part time. Just ignorant. Get real.



I am a single person with a dog and I assure you my dog is very happy and I work a full time job. No suffering here. I am sure he misses me when I am gone...I know I miss him when I am at work...but SUFFER? No, missing somebody is not suffering or animal abuse.



Comments like this just rub me the wrong way. I see dogs who are owned by people who have somebody who is home most of the day, dogs who are just shoved into the back yard and ignored or are just there and not loved and cherished...I'd dare say my dog, even when left alone while I am at work...is better off than those dogs.



And because I am a single person I should not own a dog because I have a job? That's just asinine.
10-25-2008 07:54 PM
Marie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dieselsmom View Post

Also, some people are very afraid of dogs. I have a six pound little dog and the electrician that came and did some work for us was deathly afraid of him.



One time a little kid followed me around the neighborhood while I was walking my dog. When he finally got my dog's attention he yelled "nooo!" and ran a few feet away. Then he started following us again. I couldn't shake the little bugger.
10-25-2008 07:34 PM
GhostUser
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marie View Post

People aren't uptight because they don't want their pets to be pounced on.







Also, some people are very afraid of dogs. I have a six pound little dog and the electrician that came and did some work for us was deathly afraid of him. And I don't take my little guy to dog parks because he is too small and when I take him for a walk in our neighborhood, he is on a leash because I respect other peoples lawns and for his safeties sake. With a leash on him, I can yank him out of harms way if some monstrous dog comes charging at him.
10-25-2008 09:37 AM
thalestral There are plenty of beaches here in the UK that allow unleashed dogs. Owners with small dogs are advised to go to the beaches where dogs must remain on leads.
10-24-2008 05:11 PM
Marie People aren't uptight because they don't want their pets to be pounced on.



I've had unleashed dogs run up to my dog a couple of times. One time it looked like the dog was about to bite her. I grabbed her up before the other dog could get ahold of her and the owner came running over and pulled her dog away by the collar. Another time I saw the dog coming and picked her up before the dog reached us. The dog was jumping all over me to get at her. It wouldn't be sad at all if people like that kept their dogs on their leads.
10-24-2008 02:41 PM
daisy10207 Well, there are many beaches in my town where every single dog is off-leash. Not sure if they are "officially" off-leash, but everyone who lives here takes their dogs off-leash there. It would be sad if dogs were kept on leash all the time just because of uptight people.
10-24-2008 01:53 PM
Marie adding - I'm not saying there aren't any unleashed public areas. It's just that I've never seen them.
10-24-2008 01:39 PM
Marie I'm not talking about dog parks.



If you're on a public beach.. you should keep your dog leashed. I've never been to a public area where dogs were allowed to run around unleashed. Some people let their dogs run around, but they aren't supposed to.
10-24-2008 11:14 AM
daisy10207 Well, of course we don't let her run around wild on the street! We take her to designated beaches, dog parks and other places where all the dogs are off leash. Luckily we live in a town where there are lots of options. I have sympathy for the small dogs but at the same time, if you take your small dog to a dog park where you know there are big dogs running off-leash, you have to know that it might get "pounced on" because that is just what dogs do and how they play with each other. What, my dog is not allowed to play off-leash because you have a small dog nearby?
10-24-2008 09:27 AM
Marie Please don't let your dog run free in public areas. It's not really fun for little dogs to be suddenly pounced on by some big dog.
10-23-2008 11:14 PM
daisy10207 Hi everyone, I just joined and really wanted to reply to this thread because I can relate. My husband and I live in a very small condo with a balcony but no yard and wanted a dog for years. We found our girl at a local shelter when she was six months old - she is a lab/German Shepherd mix, very high energy, and very mischevious! (and the cutest thing in the world) She is now full grown and 75 lbs. At first glance NOT the best dog for a small condo (I hear this a lot) but I can tell you she is one of the happiest dogs I know. Instead of so many dogs that are just left in the backyard all day, she gets two long runs every day (most of these she is running free and not on a leash), as well as several short walks. She goes to the beach several times a week and chases seagulls and plays in the ocean. During the week, either my husband or I come home at lunch and walk her, so she is never left alone for more than a few hours. When she's at home with us, she is usually happily passed out on the couch because she's so pooped from running around! I guess my point is that you can absolutely have a dog in a small place, even a high energy dog, if you are truly committed to giving the dog tons of exercise and making sure he/she has a happy life. It is possible! (also, it's so much better for the dog than being stuck in the shelter waiting for a home...) On that note, I hope you will adopt when you do get a dog!! Good luck!
10-16-2008 04:22 AM
Kiz From experience I can say a good percentage of neutered female labs enjoy lying around in front of heaters, eating, sleeping and eating again more than anything.
10-16-2008 02:27 AM
VeggieLizzie "Somebody Else" recommended some bigger dogs.I concur and grew up with big dogs. They call them gentle giants for a reason. Newfies are great, I grew up with one that was purebred and one half newfy and german shephard. Greyhounds sound good too.



I agree if you can't get a dog walker dont get a dog. I live in NYC and that is the only reason I don't have one. Its not fair to the dog. If you live close to where you work you could take the dog out midday so that's something to consider or get a college kid to walk the dog. Its worth it. Also, if you go with a rescue organization (my mom does lab rescue so I know this for a fact) it is unlikely they will let you adopt a dog if you wont be home during the day or have a dog walker. Too many dogs come to them because the owner works all day and doesn thave time for them and they are neglected (I am not saying you would do this at all) but that's what they think.



An older dog is a wonderful idea. They make great, calm, companions and shelters have more difficulty adopting them out. Go on petfinder.org and it will give u a list of local shelters and dogs they have for adoption. Also considerng taking the "aol dog match" quiz if its still around. But you really do want a calmer dog. I wouldn't recommend most terriers, spaniels, toy breeds, labs and goldens (even though I love them). Bulldogs are low energy but stubborn and hard to train. You will find out alot so just ask us and the dog match thing on aol is good bc they do ask stuff like "do u need the dog to be easy to train", etc.



Good luck!
10-11-2008 04:15 PM
Glitterpixie
Quote:
Originally Posted by luv4sheep View Post

hey terriers arent that bad. my dog is a terrier and she hardly ever barks and she doesnt dig either. She fight collies, but no other breeds.



My dad has her daughter in an apartment and she only barks when someone knocjks at the door.



Not all dogs conform to their breed traits but traits predispose a dog of a certain breed or type to certain behavours and these definately need to be taken into account when looking for a dog.



I would guess 80% of the dogs I see about excessive barking are terriers.
10-11-2008 03:46 PM
ParrotGirl hey terriers arent that bad. my dog is a terrier and she hardly ever barks and she doesnt dig either. She fight collies, but no other breeds.



My dad has her daughter in an apartment and she only barks when someone knocjks at the door.
10-09-2008 01:11 PM
lurcherloon
Quote:
Originally Posted by Glitterpixie View Post

I would seriously not advise this, i've seen it go horribly wrong far too many times.





The absolute key thing you need to do SonicEarth is research!!! I cannot stress how important it is to look at things like breeds, ages, training and general care before you get a dog, it will save you so much stress and heartache in the future.



I like whippets, they are calm spirited little dogs but you cannot forget that they have been designed 100% to chase and kill and you need to understand this basic drive to control it. The best thing you can do is go meet some whippet owners and their dogs and ask loads of questions about the breed. You could go visit breeders and fanciers even if you have no intention of buying a dog from them.



Finally you need to consider if you are suitable for a dog at all. How much time realisticly will you have to dedicate to a dog? Take into account the time you spend working, sleeping, eating, shopping, cleaning and socialising. Do you have the funds to support a dog? Will you be able to cope if a dog develops a behavoural or health issue? Will you be able to provide the mental a physical stimulation a dog requires?



Excellent advise especially that in bold. However I would never expect a dog to spend 8 hours a day on its own without a break - its uncomfortable for the dog and they are also social animals and want to be with their pack ie you.



You have to consider your lifestyle very carefully, do you go out to friends of an evening, do you go shopping after work etc etc, this all adds to the dog being left alone with nothing to do.



Are they any dog day care centres near you or could you get a dog walker in every day?



Please think very carefully before getting a dog about the dogs needs and what you can offer it.
10-09-2008 09:57 AM
Glitterpixie
Quote:
Sealyham terrier.



Many terriers like to use their voices - not great for an apartment, they were also originally developed to kill small furry things. Sealyhams can also suffer from inherited deafness, something to also consider.
10-08-2008 08:41 PM
Angelwing Sealyham terrier.



Around here there aren't many apartment buildings that will allow dogs. I'm not sure how your city is but keep that in mind.
10-08-2008 01:13 AM
schannybaby i was going to say a big fat dog just because i love big fat dogs.. um.. i guess no. dont get a weim and dont get a pit.. don't get a staffordshire bull terrier like me either cos my baby is so needy! she's bad too. i come downstairs and she will be in the pantry.. or stockpiling shoes.. we spend a lot of time together though and she is happy.



what about a corgi?
10-07-2008 09:59 PM
LadyFaile definately see what your local shelter has to offer before settling on a specific breed. always good to research a breed before adopting one to make sure it will suit you, so go in or call and see what they've got, do some research on the ones you like most and make a decision from there. an adult dog will be much easier to manage if you're not home all day as long as it doesn't have any issues from its previous owners (ie rescued from an abusive owner, may have problems adjusting). if you are set on a specific breed look for a rescue organization that deals with that breed specifically (there are greyhound rescues out there for sure), you may have to go out of town to get it but it's worth saving one that might not have a chance otherwise rather than supporting breeders to make more puppies, and they will have adults that are in desperate need of homes.



be prepared though some shelters won't adopt out a dog to someone who is gone for much of the day. are you able to go home on lunch to let the dog out and spend some time with him/her?

anyway our pup was semi crate trained and worked out well. we had her crate set up in the kitchen with blankets in it but we left the door open with food and water and peepads and then blocked off the kitchen with a safety gate. so if she had an accident it was on kitchen floor which is easiest to clean and not on furniture etc, nothing in reach for her to get into and all that. then as she got bigger and more able to hold her bladder we stopped using the peepads and if she had an accident again it was no big deal in the kitchen. we would gently scold her and take her outside. eventually we were able to stop gating her in the kitchen. we just close doors to rooms we don't want her exploring in on her own (like my 11 year old sister in law's room full of toys she'd love to shred lol). she does still make the odd mess if she's left alone all day but she's not left alone much so it's pretty rare really.

it's not all that bad as long as you expect and don't freak out over occassional messes. they're dogs, it happens. people who expect to leave their dog alone for 8 hours a day and get mad and punish the dog for pooping on the floor should not have dogs. a favourite saying of mine when she has an oops is "sh*t happens eh puppy?" but on days where she's left alone and doesn't make any messes i praise her and give her a treat of course



but yeah there are definately breeds that are less active than others. anything bulldog related tends to be pretty lazy. bull mastiffs i've heard are great apartment dogs despite their size, as they tend to be very lazy and don't require much excercise (as adults, all rules and descriptions go out the window when they're puppies lol)
10-07-2008 09:57 PM
Mrrple I don't understand what would be wrong with a mix anyway.
10-07-2008 04:16 PM
cstadt Lhasa Apso



My dog is probably a lhasa-mix. He's a bit big for the breed (22 pounds) but he's a very good dog. I didn't train him-- I adopted him a few months ago and he's 7. Apparently, they are pretty smart, especially if he was trained so well by people who didn't pay him much attention.



He can use a pet pad, but he's never used it at my house. He's playful, but he gets tired and isn't itching to run around outside. I've got nothing of a yard (Townhouse) and he's perfectly content. He gets his biggest exercise at the disc golf park.



I have heard from people who've had them that lhasa's are way more mellow than shih-tzu's. Mine's way chill and mellow.



Wouldn't recommend a German Shepard...
10-07-2008 03:35 PM
Lovey It was just a suggestion. Two of my dogs that I got around the same time frame became the best of buddies and they are pretty much inseparable. I don't know what they would do without each other. One is a black lab, the other a golden lab mix.
10-07-2008 02:37 PM
cheekywhiskers
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lovey View Post

I don't really have suggestions on which breed you should get, but have you thought about adopting 2 dogs? That way they will have a buddy to hang out with while you are at work.



This can be a good idea for some people and not for others. Sometimes you can find a pair of older dogs that are being adopted out together, they may be genetically related or through adoption. Some smaller, less active breeds are shih tzus, Cavaliers, Lhasa Apso and dachshunds. If you are adopting older dog(s), you can get an idea of their activity level before you adopt. Some individuals from "active" breeds can be quite calm and vice versa.



If you're not too picky about the species of your companions, you could also try cats, rabbits, guinea pigs, ferrets, chinchillas or even rats (my choice if I was in your situation). Just make sure you get a same sex pair and/or surgically sterilize one or both.



It sounds like you're already doing research about dogs before you make your choice. Remember this choice will be part of your life for possibly over 10 years and will make or break the life of the animal.
10-07-2008 01:29 PM
Glitterpixie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lovey View Post

I don't really have suggestions on which breed you should get, but have you thought about adopting 2 dogs? That way they will have a buddy to hang out with while you are at work.



I would seriously not advise this, i've seen it go horribly wrong far too many times.





The absolute key thing you need to do SonicEarth is research!!! I cannot stress how important it is to look at things like breeds, ages, training and general care before you get a dog, it will save you so much stress and heartache in the future.



I like whippets, they are calm spirited little dogs but you cannot forget that they have been designed 100% to chase and kill and you need to understand this basic drive to control it. The best thing you can do is go meet some whippet owners and their dogs and ask loads of questions about the breed. You could go visit breeders and fanciers even if you have no intention of buying a dog from them.



Finally you need to consider if you are suitable for a dog at all. How much time realisticly will you have to dedicate to a dog? Take into account the time you spend working, sleeping, eating, shopping, cleaning and socialising. Do you have the funds to support a dog? Will you be able to cope if a dog develops a behavoural or health issue? Will you be able to provide the mental a physical stimulation a dog requires?
10-07-2008 12:55 PM
ParrotGirl The walks will probably be fine. Yes he/she would probably like a garden, but if they are from a shelter they will not have had acess to gardens so will not miss it. Two walks a day is more exercise than many dogs get.
10-07-2008 12:52 PM
Lovey I don't really have suggestions on which breed you should get, but have you thought about adopting 2 dogs? That way they will have a buddy to hang out with while you are at work.
10-07-2008 12:46 PM
Kiz Well, if a particular sort of dog needs a large fenced in area then that is what he or she needs.
10-07-2008 08:39 AM
SonicEarth My parents have a greyhound, so I know how they can be. She just lies around all day. =P I was looking at a whippet because they are similar to greyhounds, in that they like to lie around all day, but are a bit more active and social. If I do get a dog, it will be from a rescue and not some horrible puppy mill. I'd like to get one that around 2 years old and already housebroken. The only thing that concerns me is that whippets need lots of exercise. I don't mind walking him a few times a day, but a few websites said they need a large fenced-in area to run around in. Will walking them during the week and maybe taking them to a dog park on the weekend be okay?
This thread has more than 30 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off