PDA

View Full Version : An article about vegan fanaticism



paulwalkersgirl
July 25th, 2008, 01:00 AM
My step-mother & father discovered this article in 'Sunday Magazine' the other month and kept it for me. They thought I'd find it interesting. :) I just typed it up for ya'll to read. Tell me what you think.




Tofu Warrior (Sunday Magazine)


Less than one per cent of the population follows a vegan diet, yet those who do claim it can make you feel better, live longer and even save the planet. But how much fun can it be? Our erstwhile devotee spills the (soya) beans on a descent into fanaticism.

Story: Stephen Lacey

There I am, on Rue Montorgueil in Paris, staring through the window of Stohrer, one of the city’s most famous patisseries. I’m drooling as I eye off the display of perfectly formed éclairs, criollo and le baba au rhum. But for me, it’s a case of look but don’t touch. I can’t enjoy even one bite. Not one lousy little crumb.
Am I diabetic? On a crash diet? Allergic to pastry? Or just out of Euros? None of the above. I am what is known as a vegan nut job.
While a vegetarian doesn’t eat anything that has a face, a vegan takes this further, refusing to eat anything derived from anything with a face. This rules out dairy products and eggs, plus a whole host of obscure ingredients that are animal sourced.
I’d been a vegetarian for around a decade, when my wife read an article about dairy cows.
“They’re exploited for their milk. I’m turning vegan,” she told me. I agreed to follow suit.
Like most things that eventually become fanatical obsessions – golf or model trains for example – our shift to veganism started out innocently enough; we simply abstained from obvious animal products.
Even at this early stage, it wasn’t easy. Every meal had to be prepared from scratch and we ended up with a huge pile of vegan cookbooks, including a book of desserts entitled Sinfully Vegan. To be honest, the idea of a vegan dessert being sinful is as likely as Fred Nile dressing in leather and growing a handlebar moustache for Mardi Gras. The fact is, tofu is never sinful. Horrible, yes. Bland, no doubt. But sinful, are you kidding?
We almost exhausted the world’s supply of soya beans. Open our fridge and you were confronted with a slimy, white wall of bean curd. Then there was the soy margarine, soy sausages, soy bacon rashers, soy chicken drumsticks, and soy burgers. Plus, of course, soy milk. Litres of the stuff.
We dined in vegan restaurants, visited vegan shops to purchase vegan supplies, and filled our wardrobes with vegan-friendly clothing.
We even read magazines devoted to the vegan lifestyle. These publications were dominated by woefully pale, righteous folk telling stories about how vegans live a longer, healthier life.
A couple of years into our veganism, we started to become acquainted with ‘E numbers’. This is the system that denotes additives in foods. We printed out a list of E numbers, indicating which ‘possibly’ or ‘almost certainly’ derived from animal products.
Armed with out list, supermarket shopping became like cracking the Da Vinci Code and took about as long. We knew E120 was cochineal (a red colouring taken from the bodies of pregnant beetles), E441 was gelatin (a thickening agent by boiling down animal bones and ligaments) and E627 was disodium 5’-Guanylate (a flavour enhancer that ‘may’ come from sardines).
It didn’t take long to discover that virtually everything on the supermarket shelves included the by-product of some unfortunate dead critter.
Surprise, surprise, the dinner party invitations started drying up. Who could blame the hosts? We were just too hard to cater for. We lost count of the number of times we were served a vegetable stack or asparagus risotto (sans parmesan cheese).
Many a time we’d sneak out to the host’s kitchen to check that forbidden ingredients weren’t being used (they usually were, in the form of a dreaded E number). Then we’d have to make our excuses and leave.
We became more fanatical as the years rolled on. It reached the stage where we wouldn’t eat from pots and pans that had been used in the preparation of animal products. A visitor once cooked an omelette at our house and we threw the frying pan away.
Being a vegan is difficult enough, but more so when you work as a travel writer. There isn’t even a word for vegan in many places, so we learnt to say, “I’m a vegetarian” in 10 languages, adding, “And we don’t eat cheese, eggs or milk.” In response, most people just made the universal sign for crazy.
I searched Rome, eventually finding a carton of soy milk in, of all places, a pharmacy. My ‘medicine’ cost the equivalent of a day’s pay and tasted like grass, but I gulped it down and bought another.
Back home, I started to question my choice to become vegan. I was losing touch with all sense of reason, as the fanaticism began to feed off itself. The cause – animal liberation – was becoming less important than its obsessive instrumentation.
It reached the point where I was checking my wife’s shopping to see if she was sneaking any forbidden items into the mix. It came to a head when I discovered she’d purchased a Milko Chew and eaten it on the way home.
“How can you do this?” I screamed at her, enraged and brandishing the telltale wrapper.
“Listen to yourself,” she reasoned. “You’re bloody crazy. We’re both bloody crazy.”
Then I was berated by a vegan friend for eating honey on my toast. “You’re so selfish. Bees are imprisoned so you can have that honey,” he snarled.
The final straw came when one of the vegan magazines informed me I’d have to give up beer and wine because they’re filtered with isinglass (derived from fish) or bone char.
By this stage I was losing weight, having dizzy spells and dreaming actual dreams about eating a big, fat juicy steak.
We didn’t crack right away. We sort of slid. My wife bought some natural yoghurt and we started with that. For us, it was a big step.
Then, one Saturday afternoon, my parents took us out for fish and chips. We smothered it in salt and vinegar and enjoyed it while watching the little trawlers out on the bay and the kids chasing seagulls. We felt as if we’d rejoined the human race.
A month later, I went to my local butcher and asked for two pieces of his best scotch fillet. I took the steak home, cooked it slowly over a flame grill and we ate it with black pepper and a slice of lemon.
Oh God, it was tasty – tasty in a way tofu could never hope to be. There was no going back.
So how do I feel about eating animals now? About exploiting them, just so I can enjoy a good meal? Not too bad, actually.
Being top of the food chain has its privileges, and one of those is being able to eat anything you damn well please. I just keep reminding myself that if cows had a big enough brain, grew opposable thumbs and turned carnivorous, they’d do the same to us. SM.

Kristen4382
July 25th, 2008, 01:08 AM
I remember reading that article and thinking very bad [and not in the good, kinky way] thoughts about the idiot who wrote it. You retyped that whole thing!?!! I looked for it online but couldn't find it, and couldn't be bothered writing it haha. Hated it because the ex-vegan [seriously, who reverts back to meat eating!!??!?!] was telling the omni's exzactly what they wanted to hear/what they thought already.

Daniel [ex bf with similar music taste] kept it for me as he thought i'd find it interesting too... turns out it brought out my rage.

paulwalkersgirl
July 25th, 2008, 01:13 AM
Yep, I retyped it all. I love typing too much, I think. :p hahahaha

If I was a vegan fanatic like that, I'd consider going back to at least many vegetarian, not to being omnivore again.

I'll never be a vegan fanatic like that. Not to the point where I forget about why I did in the first place animal rights[mainly for that], the environment etc. Punishing yourself like that is not the way to go, imo.

Fruity
July 25th, 2008, 01:26 AM
I remember reading that article and thinking very bad [and not in the good, kinky way] thoughts about the idiot who wrote it.
Heh, same here. I actually removed it from the magazine so that my parents wouldn't read it and become even more misinformed about veg*nism than they already are.

What was really interesting was the letters page of the Sunday Mag a week later; there were a couple of excellent responses. From memory, I think that one of them was from a vegan who said veg cooking can be wonderful and rewarding if done well, including the fact that his/her omni friends often asked for recipes. The other, I think, was from a long-term l/o veg defending vegans and expressing admiration for their dedication to the cause.

Anyway, it was nice to see those letters the next week (and not single letter in support of the article!)

sybaritik
July 26th, 2008, 01:21 AM
I agree with some of the points in the article but that last paragraph is pretty typical OTT stuff from veg*ns who have abandoned the lifestyle and are trying to assuage their guilt.



Like you said Lisa, they could've gone back to being a vegetarian as it's not a hard lifestyle to maintain is it.

However, I think if someone is dreaming about meat that's a pretty big clue that they're really not comfortable with the veg*n lifestyle. In that situation, I think it's important for a person to make some adjustments so that they keep their mental health on the level.

But....If I ever found myself in their situation, rather than return to rabid omnivorism, I'd try to make some compromises. I'm hoping that never happens to me....I'm deliberately as unfanatical as I can possibly be about my veganism so that I don't end up abandoning the lifestyle at some stage e.g. I just don't worry about things like cochineal. I wouldn't go out of my way to eat it, but if it happens to be in something and there's no alternative at that moment, I just deal with it.

jnh783
July 26th, 2008, 01:50 AM
Judging from the last paragraph I dont think he was ever vegan.
Its one thing to cave in and what you're not meant to, but its something else to have your whole attitude towards animals change just like that. I think this article is just having a shot at vegans.

erin84
July 26th, 2008, 10:51 PM
What did he expect when all he seemed to eat was soy products? He doesn't mention grains, beans, pulses, vegetables ... just soy milk and mock meats. Well that would make me crazy too!

Having strong convictions is never easy. But its worth it! This guy needed help with his veganism - he needed the support of people other than his wife by the sounds of it.

kali
July 27th, 2008, 05:39 AM
I agree with some of the points in the article but that last paragraph is pretty typical OTT stuff from veg*ns who have abandoned the lifestyle and are trying to assuage their guilt.


yeah. just trying to talk himself into thinking hes made the right decision when deep down he knows its wrong.

Smurfbabe
July 27th, 2008, 05:50 AM
I really enjoyed the article until the ending. I agree with a lot of what he is saying - sometimes you do lose sight of why you're vegan and just become overly obsessed and finicky to the point where you're life becomes fairly difficult. I'm not saying this happens to everyone, but I can understand how it can.
I've struck a balance that I'm happy enough with for myself - I call myself a strict vegetarian because I love going out to eat too much and if there's a trace amount of dairy in my food I will deal with it.
I find it amazing that after being vegan he could rationalise going back to eating meat as 'humans are top of food chain' and 'cows are dumb.' I will NEVER think that way....and I'm one of the people who really loved eating meat!

Waikikamukau
July 27th, 2008, 07:45 AM
It sounds like he was never really into veganism in the first place, it was "my wife is the cook and she said we're switching"... If you don't actually feel for the ethical stance you've taken, you can only be hurting things by making the switch.

It also sounds like they weren't trying to eat healthy, which of course is going to make it difficult. If you aren't getting proper nutrition you're going to start craving certain foods.


Being top of the food chain has its privileges, and one of those is being able to eat anything you damn well please. I just keep reminding myself that if cows had a big enough brain, grew opposable thumbs and turned carnivorous, they’d do the same to us.

This logic is horrible and makes me think the whole article was made up just to insult veganism. I find it hard to believe that someone who really thinks this could ever have believed in "animal liberation" as he says. Yes, we can eat anything we please... And we can also choose not to eat it, which is sort of the whole point. We're intelligent enough to see what we're doing is wrong. If he ever were truly vegan he must've believed that at one point, but his ethics couldn't compare to his inability to withstand societal pressures and food cravings. That's fairly sad.

And the cow thing is just ridiculous... Yet I bet more people that read the article nodded their heads and thought "good point!" than disagreed

:|

beepbeeplove
August 28th, 2008, 08:27 AM
Probably became vegan from a bad article and didn't research it properly.. gosh, it sounds like it was written by an omni :brood:
I'd probably go back to omni if all I ate was soy though, ew.

MokaPot
September 4th, 2008, 04:11 AM
It sounds like he and his wife burnt out. Their obsession became pathological and to the point where they were prisoners of their own fears. It shouldn't be that way. It is a shame they weren't friends with any long-term and happy vegans who could have supported them and acted as inspiration.

I agree with the comments about the soy! What were these recipe books that they collected???

ultramilitance
October 27th, 2008, 06:39 AM
These people sound like they live 4 greed.i dont know how anyone can go back to eating the flesh of the innocent creating higher demand 4 pain suffering not to mention the fact that earth would be better off without these kind of leeches draining all that is good and pure and churning out pollution,death and greed.

Toast
October 27th, 2008, 06:57 AM
He didn't even explain why people are vegan, he made it sound like vegans do it to make their dinner party hosts uncomfortable. He really skimmed over the dairy cow part didn't he.

What a idiot!:mad:

paulwalkersgirl
October 27th, 2008, 07:17 AM
That article makes me feel really sad. :(