You are viewing the VeggieBoards archive.
To view the regular site or join please click here.


PDA

View Full Version : cloning the extinct Tasmanian tiger


mouse
10-22-03, 05:43 PM
This is a fascinating article. What are your thoughts?

Extinct Thylacine May Live Again
AFP

Get a Closer Look at the Thylacine.

Oct. 21, 2003 — From its vault in Sydney's Australian Museum, a pickled Tasmanian tiger pup has brought the prospect of reviving an extinct species to the verge of reality, bringing mixed reactions of wonder and terror.

More than 60 years after its extinction, the museum launched a project to clone the Tasmanian tiger, more correctly known as the thylacine, a lost icon of Australia's island state. This pup's DNA was the starting point, due to its remarkable state of preservation.

For proponents, it is a chance to undo a terrible mistake that humans made. Human hunting was responsible for wiping out the thylacine in Tasmania, its final refuge. But for diehard critics, it is "playing God."

The driving force behind the project is museum director Michael Archer, who has dismissed the frequent comparisons with Jurassic Park.

"The thylacine's world is not gone," Archer told AFP. "The ecological system of which it was the top carnivore is still the same.

"I think we have a moral obligation to bring it back if we can do it," he continued. "I think this as a terrible thing humans did, and most religious people agree.

The thylacine was hailed as a wonder of nature when Europeans first saw it. A doglike marsupial, it is considered a perfect case of "convergent evolution", where similar environments and lifestyles produce similar features in totally unrelated species.

By the time Europeans arrived in Australia, the introduction of the dingo had already eliminated the thylacine from the mainland. European farmers in Tasmania soon dubbed it a pest, hunting it to extinction. The last thylacine died in captivity in 1936.

Remarkably little is known about the pup, which has been in the museum’s possession since 1866. Researchers have deduced that it had been in its mother's pouch for about four months and was nearly full term. It is assumed that the mother was killed.

By pure chance, whoever preserved it used alcohol, an unusual step that left most of its DNA intact more than a century later.

Work with its DNA provided the impetus to get the project going, and genetic material has since been obtained from at least three additional thylacines.

Because hundreds of thylacine remains are in collections around the world, Archer said the possibility is wide open for eventually returning a viable population to the wild.

Among the hurdles to be overcome is getting dead DNA to act again as living DNA. The DNA must be extracted and multiplied, using yeast or bacteria cells.

A suitable host animal will be needed, probably the thylacine's distant cousin, the Tasmanian devil. More needs to be known about that animal's breeding cycle and its DNA needs to be sequenced.

If the thylacine can be cloned, however, it has huge implications for conservation. Some critics fear people may cease to care about conservation at all.

Researchers said the project is massively under-funded. Only a single researcher has been working fulltime on the project, with limited laboratory facilities.

The roughly $120,000 Australian ($83,000 U.S.) so far spent has been largely funded privately, partly by a trust with Tasmanian connections.

Archer and his colleagues are seeking more funding, promising in return one of the most exciting scientific projects of the present day.


< news main


Name: Tasmanian Tiger, aka Thylacine (Thylacinus cynocephalus)
Primary Classification: Marsupialia (Marsupials)
Location: In recent times, southwestern Tasmania.
Habitat: Preferred open forests and grasslands.
Diet: Wallabies, kangaroos, small birds and other small mammals.
Size: Up to 6.5 feet in length and 66 lbs in weight.
Description: Sandy brown to gray coat, with 15 to 20 dark stripes from shoulders to tail; short, thick fur; large, dog-like head; powerful jaws with long canines; short, stiff tail.
Cool Facts: Their jaws could open 120 degrees, wider than any other known mammal. They were once Australia's largest carnivorous marsupial.
Conservation Status: Extinct

muppetcow
10-23-03, 01:34 PM
While I agree that it would be neat to undo humankind's mistakes, I think any kind of cloning is scary business and I'm opposed to it.

Draekyn
10-23-03, 01:42 PM
I have some serious doubts about the ability to do this. Even if they are successful in producing a clone, there will be no genetic variation. We've seen lots of bad things as a result of inbreeding in other animals, and it seems like there would be similar issues here.

1vegan
10-23-03, 01:48 PM
Cloning is wrong.

They are only doing this cause a zoo could make lots of money with such a tiger.

If they want to save them from extinction they should restore their natural habitat.

chiaraluna
10-23-03, 11:06 PM
"I think we have a moral obligation to bring it back if we can do it," he continued. "I think this as a terrible thing humans did, and most religious people agree.

What difference does it make whether or not religious people agree? I am not religious, and I am strongly opposed to cloning. As I do not believe in God, it is difficult for me to say that we are "playing God," but I do believe that by cloning, we will be tampering with nature and with the universal pattern. Man already has too much power; we do not need more.